The Guardian 08.05.08
Dahr Jamail
Beyone the Green Zone. Haymarket Books
In the introduction to his book, he quotes
the story of an indigenous Canadian hunter who was called to give evidence in
an inquiry into a planned dam that would flood his homeland and destroy his
traditional way of life. The hunter was asked to swear on the Bible that he
would tell the truth, but he had never seen a Bible and wondered how this
miraculous truth telling instrument worked. ‘He spoke with the translator at
length,’ writes Jamail, ‘and finally the translator looked to the judge. ‘He
does not know whether he can tell the truth. He says he can tell only what he
knows.’
Guardian, Saturday 12 April 2008
Jean-Paul Sartre. Nausea
‘Every exiting thing is born without
reason, prolongs itself out of weakness and dies by chance. I leaned back and
closed my eyes. But the image, forewarned, immediately leaped up and filled my
closed eyes with existences: existence is a fullness which man can never
abandon.’
Samuel
Beckett, extract from The Unnamable.
And the
spectators? Where are they?
You
didn't notice, in the anguish of waiting, never noticed you were waiting alone.
That's the show: waiting alone, in the restless air, for it to begin, for
something to begin, for there to be something else but you. For the power to
rise, the courage to leave. You try and be reasonable: perhaps you are blind,
probably deaf. The show is over, all is over? But where then is the hand, the
helping hand? (Or merely charitable? Or the hired hand?) It's a long time
coming, to take yours and draw you away.
That's
the show (free, gratis and for nothing): waiting alone, blind, deaf. You don't
know where, you don't know for what: for a hand to come and draw you away,
somewhere else (where perhaps it's worse). (my
emphasis)
I have no judgement about myself and my
life.
There is nothing I am quite sure about.
I have no definite convictions-
Not about anything, really.
I know only that I was born and exist,
and it seems that I have been carried
along.
I exist on the foundation of something
I do not know. In spite of all
uncertainties,
I feel a solidity underlying all
existence,
and continuity in my mode of being.
A native American elder once described his
own inner
struggles in this manner.
‘Inside of me there are two dogs. One of
these dogs is
mean and evil. The other dog is good. The
mean dog
fights with the good dog all the time.’
When asked which dog wins, he reflected
for a moment and
replied.
‘The one that I feed the most.’